The Pros and Cons of No-Poaching Agreements, According to Industry Insiders


In conclusion, the prevalence of no-poaching agreements (NPAs) among business groups in India raises critical questions about their compatibility with competition laws and free market principles. While the objective of retaining skilled employees is essential for companies, NPAs have come under increasing scrutiny by competition authorities worldwide. The US, EU, and several member states have taken enforcement actions against NPAs, considering them as harmful to competition in the labor market, stifling employee mobility, suppressing wages, and impeding new market entrants.

India’s competition law, inspired by US and EU models, provides a framework for addressing NPAs. The Competition Commission of India (CCI) can examine NPAs under Section 3(3), which addresses anti-competitive horizontal agreements, including cartels. This is particularly relevant as NPAs influence employee compensation and control the supply of skilled labor, impacting the employment marketplace. Moreover, amendments to the Competition Act extend its reach to HR and consulting firms facilitating such agreements.

While employee retention is a challenge, resorting to illegal NPAs is not a constructive solution. The CCI has yet to rule on NPAs, but it is vital for companies, recruiters, and HR professionals to adhere to competition laws in their employment policies. Ignoring these regulations can result in substantial fines for both companies and their executives. In navigating this landscape, employers can explore legally sound strategies, such as carefully crafted employment agreements, to retain valuable employees within the boundaries of competition laws.

In a dynamic environment where employee mobility remains high, businesses must strike a balance between their interests and compliance with competition laws. Crafting strategic solutions that comply with regulations will not only help companies retain skilled personnel but also foster healthy competition and contribute to a thriving labor market.

Read More